At
Gardenweb, in their furniture forum, there was
a discussion about 8 way hand tied sofas versus those using Pirelli webbing. I have to tell you, this comes up a lot. I know that I had many customers ask me about this. I will give you my opinion, but in the end you are obviously going to have to choose for yourself.
If you don’t know, these two phrases refer to the way the seating on your sofa is supported. With Pirelli webbing, there is generally a series of coil or sinuous springs covered by the webbing. The webbing itself is a highly resilient material that is used in everything from airlines to automobiles. Few will deny that it is strong and wears well. On the other hand, 8-way hand tied uses a series of twine strings tied, by hand, 8 ways to support the seat. Many swear by it as both traditional and superior. It is not unusual to hear stories of old 8 way hand tied sofas lasting for 50 years.
But which is better?
First off, 8 way hand tied is going to be more expensive than a sofa using Pirelli webbing. That is just a fact. So, if cost is a concern, you may want to go ahead and cross off 8 way hand tied from your list of options.
As for which is actually superior, it is hard to argue with history. On the other hand, Pirelli webbing has not been around long enough to truly know. I do know this: it lasted as long as I wanted my sofa. I have never owned 8-way hand tied because I felt it was too expensive, but it is traditionally considered to be a sign of fine craftsmanship (hence the price).
I guess what I would tell you is that you have to consider what you want out of your sofa. If you want to spend a lot of money on something that you plan to hand down for generations, then you may want to watch for that 8 way hand tied Italian leather sofa. For most of us, though, the Pirelli webbing is more practical. It will surely last 10-20 years (long enough to get the kids out of the house), and you will be able to get it at a much more reasonable price.
Hope this helps,
The Furniture Guy
